Sweets & Treats

Sam & Jake's is proud to serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream from Madison, Wisconsin. We are always rotating our case, so call ahead to see if your favorite is in for you to enjoy!

Popular Flavors:

• New York Cherry
• Butter Pecan
• Ultimate Oreo
• Zanzibar Chocolate
• Maple Nut
• Pistachio Nut
• Fat Elvis
• Blueberry Cheesecake

Our seasonal line up of ice cream flavors has arrived! Our festive and flavorful dips include Raspberry, Sorbet , Coconut, and Strawberry Soy. As always, you can order our GIANT Caramel Apples in caramel, caramel with chopped peanuts, caramel and chocolate, and our house specialty, a Caramel Apple Pie Apple that is drenched in gooey caramel, dipped in white chocolate, then rolled in a brown sugar and cinnamon crumble. For the fans of savory flavors, try our Party Trays and Hostess Boxes. These contain your choice of block cheese or cheese curds, sausage, and pretzel bread. We can create a tray to suit your event or occasion.

In addition to our 28 flavors, we can customize any sundae from our list of toppings, or you can choose one of our spectacular SIGNATURE SUNDAES. For those who would rather sip their scoop, Sam & Jake's makes absolutely the thickest and creamiest REAL hand-dipped milkshakes around. Specialties from our fountain include old-fashioned sodas, floats, and creamosas (Italian style soda).

We are also serving a wide variety of Island Oasis Smoothies, gourmet coffee and frozen coffee specialties, and decant gourmet hot cocoas. Check out the recipe tab for great ways to use Island Oasis at home!

Ice Cream Cakes and pies are available in our freezer case, or you can custom order yours for any special occasion. Homemade ice cream "Sam"wiches (the BIGGEST you've ever seen), chocolate covered bananas, and other frozen novelties are also available in our freezer case.

Our Signature Gift Baskets are also available. We offer a savory cheese and sausage selection, an ice cream lovers delight, and for a real sweet tooth, one chock full of nostalgic candies. We can also help you create your own with combination of taste tempting treats that might include our Caramel Pecan Trixies, Chocolate Dipped Oreos, Chocolate Pretzel Rods, Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers, and Chocolate Covered Fortune Cookies. You can see these tasty treats pictured on our home page.